The Right Coast |
|
Thoughts from San Diego on Law, Politics, and Culture
Right Coasters
Gail Heriot Saikrishna Prakash Michael Rappaport Maimon Schwarzschild Thomas Smith Christopher Wonnell Email Us Gail Heriot Saikrishna Prakash Michael Rappaport Maimon Schwarzschild Thomas Smith Christopher Wonnell Links Andrew Sullivan Atlantic Blog The Buck Stops Here Corporate Law Blog Crescat Sententia Crooked Timber Curmudgeonly Clerk Daniel Drezner En Banc EveTushnet.Com FreeSpace How Appealing Instapundit Law and Econ Blog Little Green Footballs Legal Theory Blog The Leiter Reports Marginal Revolution Overlawyered Pejmanesque ProfBainbridge.Com Punishment Theory Rasmusen Weblog SFA Politics & Relig Southern Appeal SpoonsExperience USS Clueless The Volokh Conspiracy The Yin Blog Archives The Bear Flag League Aaron's Rantblog (LA) Absinthe & Cookies Accidental Jedi (Fres) Angry Clam (LA) Baldilocks BlogoSFERICS (Expat) BoifromTroy (LA) CalBlog (Los Angeles) California Republic Citizen Smash(SD) Cobb (Los Angeles) Daily Pundit (SF) Dale Franks e-Claire(Northern CA) Fresh Potatoes(Orang) Infinite Monkeys The Interocitor (LA) The Irish Lass (Sacra) Left Coast Conserv. Lex Communis (Fres) Master of None (LA) Miller's Time (Sac) Molly's Musings (SD) Mulatto Boy (LA) Howard Owens (Vent) Pathetic Earthlings) Patio Pundit Patterico's Pontifications(LA) PrestoPundit (Orange) QandO Right on the Left Beach Shark Blog (Expat) Slings and Arrows (SD) So. Cal Law Blog (LA) Tone Cluster Window Manager Xrlq (Orange) |
January 05, 2005
The Rights of Adoptees and the Law of Unintended Consequences By Gail Heriot The Associated Press ran a story earlier this week on a new law in New Hampshire that allows adults who were adopted as children complete access to their birth records. The story is told in a way that is sympathetic to the adoptees and their often long efforts to learn about the circumstances of their birth. And that sympathy is entirely appropriate; it's easy to feel for them and their plight. I am not certain how I would have re-acted had I been an adopted child. Would I want to know who my birth parents were? Or would I prefer not to know? Occasionally, one reads about the extraordinary birth moth er child reunion--like the one involving Joni Mitchell and the child she gave up before she became famous. But the typical case may be a lot less happy. The odds that the birth parents were drug addicts, mentally ill, or in trouble with the law are not insubstantial. In the end, it may be better to nurture a fantasy that your mother was a Canadian folksinger on her way to stardom (or a Martian, as the little boy who grew up in my neighborhood when I was a child liked to claim) and concentrate instead on your adopted parents. What worries me is whether these new open access laws (the article states that Oregon, Alabama, Alaska and Kansas have similar laws mandating unfettered access) might have some unintended consequences. In the modern world, many pregnant women who believe they are not in a position to rear a child may be on the fence between adoption and abortion. Is it possible that the knowledge that there is no way to prevent the child from eventually learning her identity will tip the balance in favor of abortion? Obviously, I cannot say with anything approaching certainty. But if it does, the victory in New Hampshire for today's adopted children will turn out to be a loss for adopted children who might have been. |